You've Never Tasted Butter Quite Like This

Our butter company makes a full range of gourmet flavors in Toms River, NJ

Do you spread the same bland butter over your toast every morning? Would you like to try something sweeter, spicier or more flavorful? Butter Me Up offers gourmet butter for sale. Our family owned and operated butter company based in Toms River, NJ makes everything from brown sugar cinnamon butter to honey sriracha butter.

You can check out our butter flavors, including vegan flavors, on the Menu page. When you're ready to buy butter, you can:

 


  • Find our butter for sale at one of our many markets. See our Events page to see where we are located
  • Order butter online in advance to pick up at any of our markets
  • Order butter online and schedule our local delivery services
  • Order butter online and arrange for a shipment to your address
  • Contact us to order a custom gift set or party favor set


 

 

If you need something to spread your butter on, we recommend one of our delicious scones for sale.

 

Butter

Butter

From sweet butter to savory herb butter, we make it all.

Scones

Scones

Spread our butter on a classic or specialty flavored scone.

Party Favors

Party Favors

Give a one-of-a-kind gift or party favor that's sure to impress.

Butter of the Month Club

Butter of the Month Club

Taste unique butter and scone flavors every month.

We love what we do


The husband-wife team running our butter company have been doing this for more than four years. We're passionate about making rich, flavorful butter, and we hope you enjoy eating it just as much as we enjoy making it. If you have any questions about our ingredients or ordering butter, call 732-930-1116 now to talk to our team.


Get butter and scones delivered to your door every month

Can't get enough of our unique scone and butter flavors? We'll ship them right to your door once a month. Whether you just want something fun for breakfast one morning or you want to step up your cooking, you're sure to love our gourmet treats. Our butter could be just the right addition to your:

Cake: try baking with our lavender butter

Cake: try baking with our lavender butter

Sauce: add our garlic basil butter to your next dish

Sauce: add our garlic basil butter to your next dish

Roast chicken: try an herbal butter like garlic lemon thyme with your chicken

Roast chicken: try an herbal butter like garlic lemon thyme with your chicken

Joining our Butter of the Month club is all that you need to do. You can choose a three-, six- or nine-month-long subscription or a year-long subscription. To get the details, go to the Butter of the Month page now.