Salted Butter or Unsalted? How About Something New?

You'll love the unique butter flavors that we make in Toms River, NJ

Why limit yourself to only two kinds of butter when there are so many more options? Instead of picking up butter from a chain brand at a grocery store in Toms River or Asbury Park, NJ, turn to Butter Me Up. Making unique types of butter only takes a little imagination and our skilled team.

We make a wide range of gourmet butter flavors, including:


  • Sundried tomato
  • Sriracha honey
  • Walnut honey
  • Blueberry
  • Brown sugar cinnamon



Those are just a few of the flavors that you can choose from. See all of our butter flavors by going to the Menu page now.

Don't eat dairy? You're in luck. Our butter makers make vegan butter that's just as rich and creamy as our dairy-based butter. You can even get vegan maple bacon butter with a satisfyingly sweet, smoky flavor. When you need any information about our ingredients, we'll be happy to provide it. Use the form on the Contact Us page now to ask about vegan butter ingredients.